The Personalities of 8 Northern New Jersey Towns: Which One Fits You?
Maplewood, South Orange, Summit, Chatham, Millburn, Short Hills, Montclair and Westfield each have their own rhythm. The trick is finding the one that feels like you.
One of the biggest surprises about moving from New York City to Northern New Jersey is discovering just how different the towns can feel—even when they’re only a few miles apart.
People often start their home search with a list of practical considerations: budget, commute, bedrooms, bathrooms, property taxes. All important. But there’s another question I encourage buyers to ask: Where will you feel most at home when you’re not actually in your home?
Do you want a downtown where you can meet a friend for dinner without making a plan? A neighborhood where the sidewalks are busy on Saturday morning? A little more polish, a little more breathing room, or a little more creative energy? Are you drawn to a classic suburban setting, or do you want a place that still feels connected to the urban life you love?
There’s no single personality that defines any town, of course. Every community has its quieter corners, unexpected gems and residents who defy the stereotype. But after spending time in these towns, you begin to appreciate their different rhythms.
Here’s my take on eight Northern New Jersey communities—and the kind of person who might feel especially at home in each.
Maplewood has a certain ease about it. Think tree-lined streets, homes with architectural character, a village center that feels genuinely connected to the surrounding neighborhoods, and a community that takes its local life seriously.
There’s a creative streak here, but it doesn’t need to announce itself. It shows up in the arts, independent businesses, community events and the mix of people who make the town feel like more than a collection of pretty houses.
Maplewood Village has that appealing small-town quality where an ordinary errand can turn into a conversation. You might head out for coffee and come home an hour later because you ran into three people you know.
Maplewood might be your town if: You love a neighborhood with personality, appreciate older homes and tree-lined streets, and want community to be part of your everyday life. You like the idea of knowing your local businesses—and being known by them.
The vibe: Creative, welcoming, connected and quietly confident.
South Orange has a little more downtown energy. Its village center, train station, restaurants and performing arts scene create a lively hub, while the residential streets offer their own pockets of calm. Seton Hall University adds another layer to the town’s character.
There’s a nice balance here between suburban comfort and an active social life. You can catch a performance, meet friends for dinner or spend time around the village without feeling as though every outing requires a trip into the city.
South Orange and Maplewood share a school district and many community connections, but they don’t feel interchangeable. Where Maplewood often feels like a village organized around neighborhood life, South Orange has a more pronounced downtown pulse.
South Orange might be your town if: You want a community feel but still like a little buzz around you. You appreciate arts and culture, enjoy being near restaurants and transit, and want a downtown that plays an active role in your social life.
The vibe: Engaged, energetic, cultured and connected.
Summit feels established, confident and put together. Its downtown has a strong identity, with shops, restaurants and everyday conveniences clustered around a walkable center. The residential neighborhoods offer a range of architectural styles, from classic homes to larger properties, and the town has a distinctly well-established feel.
But Summit isn't simply about appearances. Its downtown is a real part of daily life, and its combination of commuter convenience, community amenities and residential variety makes it appealing to people who want their suburban life to function smoothly.
There's a sense of polish here, but also plenty of activity. Summit can feel lively and social without needing to lean into a big-city personality.
Summit might be your town if: You appreciate a well-defined downtown, value convenience and want a community with an established identity. You like things to feel organized and accessible, but still want independent shops, restaurants and places to gather.
The vibe: Polished, active, confident and classic.
Chatham has that traditional small-town appeal that many people picture when they imagine suburban New Jersey. The downtown is compact and approachable, with local businesses and restaurants, while the surrounding residential streets offer a range of established homes and neighborhood settings.
Its charm isn't about trying to be the next big thing. It's about a sense of continuity: a town center that serves the community, residential neighborhoods with a long history, and a lifestyle that feels grounded.
One important distinction for house hunters: Chatham Borough and Chatham Township are separate municipalities, each with its own character and housing options. It's worth looking at both rather than treating “Chatham” as one uniform experience.
Chatham might be your town if: You gravitate toward classic architecture, a traditional downtown and a community-centered lifestyle. You want a suburban setting with a strong sense of place and don't need a sprawling restaurant or nightlife scene right outside your door.
The vibe: Traditional, charming, grounded and understated.
Millburn offers a combination that many buyers find compelling: a defined downtown, established residential neighborhoods, commuter access and a range of cultural and recreational amenities. It has a practical side, but it isn't without personality.
The downtown is an important part of the experience, and the Paper Mill Playhouse adds a significant cultural dimension. Depending on where you are in town, daily life can feel centered around the village or more firmly rooted in a residential neighborhood.
Millburn appeals to people who want a community that can accommodate several priorities at once. Work, family, cultural outings, errands and a comfortable home life can all have a place in the mix.
Millburn might be your town if: You value convenience, established neighborhoods and access to cultural amenities. You want a community that feels well resourced and can support a busy life without sacrificing the pleasures of suburban living.
The vibe: Capable, established, purposeful and well rounded.
Short Hills has a different rhythm. Known for its larger homes, leafy streets and a more residential feel, it often appeals to buyers who put a premium on space, privacy and a sense of retreat.
Here, the house and the property may play a bigger role in the lifestyle decision. You might be looking for a generous yard, room to entertain, more separation from neighbors or a home that feels like an escape at the end of a busy day.
Short Hills is part of Millburn Township, but it has a distinct identity in the minds of many buyers. The experience can vary considerably by location, and proximity to shopping, transit and other daily destinations is something to assess on a property-by-property basis.
Short Hills might be your town if: You want room to spread out, appreciate a more private residential setting and see home as a place to recharge, entertain and settle in for the long term.
The vibe: Private, spacious, serene and quietly luxurious.
Montclair has a personality all its own. It's one of the places people often consider when they want to preserve a strong connection to city life while gaining more space and a different kind of home.
Part of the appeal is its cultural and culinary energy. Montclair has a substantial arts presence, a lively restaurant scene and several distinct commercial districts rather than one single downtown. Its architecture is another draw, with historic homes and a broad range of styles that give different neighborhoods their own look and feel.
Montclair also rewards exploration. The experience can change noticeably from one section of town to another, so it helps to spend time in the specific neighborhoods you're considering rather than relying on a general impression.
Montclair might be your town if: You love independent restaurants, art, architecture and a little urban unpredictability. You want a town with plenty happening, and you don't want your move to mean giving up your appetite for discovery.
The vibe: Creative, eclectic, expressive and city-minded.
Westfield has an unmistakable downtown presence. Its central shopping and dining district gives the town a lively focal point, and its residential neighborhoods offer a range of home styles and settings.
There's an ease to the way downtown and community life fit together. You can run errands, meet friends, browse shops or go out for dinner, all within a recognizable town center. For people who enjoy a strong sense of community activity, that can be a major part of the appeal.
Westfield feels like a town where the calendar can fill up naturally. It's active and social, with a traditional suburban foundation and a downtown that gives people a reason to come together.
Westfield might be your town if: You want a lively, walkable downtown, enjoy local events and restaurants, and like the idea of a community with a strong social center. You want suburban space without feeling disconnected from everyday activity.
The vibe: Sociable, lively, welcoming and community-oriented.
Here's the thing: You don't have to choose a town based on a label. And you certainly don't need to fit a stereotype to belong in a particular place.
Instead, think about the details of your actual life.
And then go beyond the downtown.
Visit on a weekday morning, when commuters are heading to the train. Come back on a Saturday afternoon. Drive through the residential streets. Stop for coffee. Notice whether people are lingering or rushing, whether the town feels energetic or quiet, and whether you can picture your own routines taking shape there.
If you're moving from New York City, pay attention to what you want to keep as much as what you want to change. Maybe it's walkability, independent businesses, cultural life or the ability to get out for dinner without planning your entire evening. Maybe you're ready for a bigger yard, a quieter street or a house with room for a new chapter—without losing the things that make a place feel like home.
Because choosing a town isn't just about where you can buy a house. It's about where you want to spend your life around it.
My advice? Don't start by asking which town is best. Start by asking what you want your everyday life to feel like. That's usually where the right search begins.
And if you're trying to narrow down the options, that's a conversation I'm always happy to have. Sometimes a few honest questions about how you live, what you love and what you want more of can tell us more than a dozen property listings ever will.
From Maplewood’s creative village feel to Montclair’s urban energy and Short Hills’ spacious retreats, explore the personalities of eight Northern NJ towns.
One of the things I love about Maplewood is that you don't have to go far to feel like you’re somewhere.
I can usually tell pretty quickly whether a house has something special.
If you’re moving from New York City to northern New Jersey, there’s a good chance someone has already told you to look at Maplewood, South Orange or Montclair.
Homeownership isn't about checking a box or following someone else's timeline. It's about creating a strategy that fits your life—today and in the future.
Getting an accepted offer is exciting. For buyers, it can feel like the hard part is over. For sellers, it can feel like the finish line is finally close. But in… Read more
There’s a very specific conversation I keep having right now with buyers coming out of Brooklyn—smart, thoughtful people who are no longer just asking “Can we afford t… Read more
Buying a home is one of the biggest purchases you’ll ever make. And homeowner’s insurance is what protects that investment. Think of it as your safety net.
Want to stay one step ahead of the market? Sign up to be on Dyanna's VIP mailing list to receive exclusive listings, real estate news and a lot more.